Scary Stories
Photo of author

I Am Not Guilty, But I Wish I Was | Horror Story

WhatsApp Group Join Now
Telegram Channel Join Now

The courtroom was silent as the verdict was read. “Not guilty.” The words echoed in my ears like a mockery of my very existence. My defense attorney patted my shoulder, but I felt nothing. I wasn’t guilty, but deep down, I wished I was.

It all started three months ago, on a fog-drenched night. I was driving home from a late shift at the hospital when my car struck something—or someone. I slammed the brakes, my heart pounding as I stepped out. The fog was so thick it clung to my skin, and visibility was nearly zero. I crouched down, expecting to find a wounded animal, but instead, I saw her.

A young woman in a pale dress, her face smeared with blood. She didn’t scream, didn’t cry. She just stared at me with lifeless eyes, her lips curling into a faint, sinister smile before she whispered, “You’ll pay.” And then, she vanished.

I couldn’t breathe. My chest tightened, and my head swirled with disbelief. I checked the area repeatedly, convinced my mind was playing tricks on me. But there was no body. Nothing. Just the oppressive fog and the faint scent of decay.

Days turned into weeks, but I couldn’t shake her face from my memory. Then the haunting began. At first, it was small things—lights flickering, cold drafts, whispers in the night. But soon, it escalated. Mirrors shattered when I looked into them, my car radio played static mixed with faint cries, and her apparition appeared at the foot of my bed every night.

The worst part was the laughter. A low, guttural chuckle that filled my room, my car, my thoughts. I was losing my grip on reality. Desperate for answers, I dug into local archives and discovered a chilling truth: she was Melissa Harper, a local woman who had gone missing 20 years ago. Her body was never found, but rumors swirled about her being buried in the woods by an unknown killer.

And then, the police came. Someone had anonymously tipped them off, claiming I had confessed to her murder. My house was searched, and to my horror, they found her necklace buried in my backyard. I had never seen it before.

The trial was swift. My lawyer argued there was no hard evidence tying me to the crime, and the lack of a body made the case circumstantial. But the townsfolk whispered behind my back, their eyes accusing. Every night, Melissa’s ghost reminded me that I would “pay.”

The verdict was in my favor, but I felt like a prisoner of my own sanity. As I walked out of the courthouse, she appeared again, her pale face inches from mine. “They’ll never believe you,” she hissed. “But you’ll know. You’ll always know.”

Now, I spend my nights in terror, wishing I had been guilty, wishing the punishment could end this torment. But Melissa’s vengeance isn’t bound by justice—it’s eternal.

The haunting didn’t stop after the trial. It grew worse. Melissa’s ghost began appearing not just at night but in mirrors, windows, even reflections in puddles. Her laughter became louder, echoing in every corner of my home, mocking my innocence. I was no longer sure if I was awake or trapped in some twisted nightmare.

One night, desperate for peace, I went back to the woods where her body was rumored to be buried. Armed with a shovel and a lantern, I dug feverishly under the ancient oak tree I’d read about in the archives. Hours passed, and just as I was ready to give up, my shovel struck something solid.

It was a box, old and rotted. My hands trembled as I opened it. Inside were Melissa’s belongings—her diary, a photograph, and a bloodstained scarf. Her final diary entries revealed the truth. She had planned to run away from an abusive relationship but was killed by her boyfriend when she tried to leave. He had buried her here and framed me, knowing I’d be at the wrong place at the wrong time.

Before I could process the discovery, a cold wind swept through the forest. Melissa appeared before me, her ghost more vivid than ever. “You found me,” she said, her voice softer this time. “But it’s too late.”

“I didn’t kill you,” I whispered. “I’m not guilty.”

She tilted her head, a flicker of sadness in her dead eyes. “I know,” she said. “But you carry my pain now. And I’ll never let you go.”

The ground beneath me began to quake, and the shadows of the forest grew longer, darker. Her laughter returned, but now it sounded like hundreds of voices joined in a macabre symphony. I screamed, clutching the diary, begging for her forgiveness, but it was useless.

The next morning, the townsfolk found my abandoned car near the edge of the woods. My footprints led deep into the forest but stopped abruptly. No one ever found me, but whispers spread about the oak tree. Some say you can still hear Melissa’s laughter there, mingled with the screams of her latest victim.

In the end, I wasn’t guilty—but I paid the ultimate price. Melissa ensured her story would never die, and neither would her vengeance.

The nightmare lives on.

WhatsApp Group Join Now
Telegram Channel Join Now

Leave a Comment