A former OnlyFans creator has called for restrictions on the use of “extraordinary ability” visas by adult content stars seeking to work in the United States, arguing that such work should not qualify under US immigration law.
Nala Ray, who was once among the top earners on OnlyFans before leaving the platform two years ago after converting to Christianity, said creators producing explicit content should not be eligible for O-1 visas, which are intended for individuals with exceptional achievements.
“Adult content is not real work and shouldn’t qualify as extraordinary ability,” Ray said in an interview. She added that she would support a ban on granting such visas to OnlyFans creators, calling the practice unethical.
The O-1 visa category is reserved for individuals who demonstrate “extraordinary ability” in fields such as science, arts, education, business or athletics, or who have a record of distinguished achievement in the film or television industry, according to US Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS). Applications must be filed by a US employer or agent and supported by evidence of national or international recognition.
Ray said she does not oppose all forms of online content creation and acknowledged that social media work can involve legitimate effort and skill. However, she drew a clear distinction between general digital content creation and explicit material.
“I don’t see adult content as contributing anything positive to society,” she said, adding that financial success alone should not determine eligibility for entry into the US.
Ray, who described herself as a former top “0.01%” creator on OnlyFans, said her experience on the platform exposed what she views as its harmful effects, including damage to mental health and personal relationships. She said maintaining popularity often required taking risks and contributed to emotional strain.
She also claimed that substance abuse is common among people working in the adult content industry, describing it as a dangerous environment that can lead to long-term personal consequences.
Pennsylvania-based immigration attorney Raymond Lahoud said the O-1B visa category has increasingly been used by influencers and digital content creators, including those with large online followings and high earnings.
“If an applicant meets the legal criteria, their platform alone does not disqualify them,” Lahoud said, noting that visa approvals are based on statutory requirements rather than moral judgments.
Ray rejected that view, arguing that the broader social impact of adult content should be considered.
“Welcoming someone solely because they make money ignores the harm this kind of content causes,” she said, calling OnlyFans a “societal harm” and warning that continued acceptance of such work could have long-term negative effects.
OnlyFans did not respond to a request for comment.